You need long-term regulatory archiving. Multi-year retention, compliance hold, eDiscovery, structured retention policies. Message Replay is a 45-day operational recovery layer, not a regulatory archive. The two coexist, but they answer different questions.
You need full mailbox backup and restore. Every folder, every flag, every metadata field, restored to a specific point in time. Backup tools are the right shape for that. Message Replay handles the per-message case, which is a different problem.
Your environment never produces missing messages. If your spam filter, mail server, and migration cadence have been clean for years and your help desk does not see recovery tickets, Message Replay is overhead you do not yet need. We would rather you call us once the recovery pattern shows up than pay for a layer you do not use.